'By Leibniz's law': Remarks on a fallacy

Link:

https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-9213.2005.00427.x

Autor/in:

Schnieder, Benjamin

Erscheinungsjahr:

2006

Medientyp:

Text

Beschreibung:

I investigate a form of argument which refers to Leibniz's law as its inference ticket (where 'Leibniz's law' is understood as the thesis that if x = y, then all properties of x are properties of y, and vice versa). Arguments of this form are often used to establish certain categorial distinctions, e.g., a distinction between kinds and properties, or a distinction between processes and events. I show that there can be deficient arguments of this form, and why. I then argue that the interesting philosophical cases of this argument form are unconvincing, since they cannot be seen as clear cases of its unproblematic variety. © The Editors of The Philosophical Quarterly, 2006.

Lizenz:

info:eu-repo/semantics/closedAccess

Quellsystem:

Forschungsinformationssystem der UHH

Interne Metadaten

Quelldatensatz: oai:www.edit.fis.uni-hamburg.de:publications/169ebe9f-e0e6-404d-8cfc-019f01f40658