Evaluation of balanced steady-state free precession (TrueFISP) and K-space segmented gradient echo sequences for 3D coronary MR angiography with navigator gating at 3 Tesla.
PURPOSE: To test the feasibility of k-space segmented gradient-echo pulse sequences for free-breathing coronary magnetic resonance angiography (cMRA) on a clinical 3T system. MATERIALS AND METHODS: T2-prepared, fat-suppressed turbo field echo (TFE, turboFLASH, SFPGR) as well as balanced TFE (b-TFE, trueFISP, FIESTA, segmented SSFP) sequences with navigator gating for prospective motion correction were applied on a 3T system equipped with a six-element phased-array cardiac coil. In 15 healthy volunteers, the right coronary artery (RCA) was examined with TFE and b-TFE sequences. Due to examination time limitations, the left coronary artery (LM/LAD) was examined exclusively with the TFE sequence in ten volunteers. Image quality was graded on a five point scale (0 = not visualized to 4 = excellent). The length, diameter and sharpness of the vessels and the contrast-to-noise ratios (CNR) were measured. RESULTS: 98 % of all major segments (proximal/middle/distal) of the RCA could be seen with the TFE sequence and 82 % with the b-TFE sequence. The image quality for the three segments was graded higher for the TFE sequence (2.7/2.7/1.5) than for the b-TFE sequence (1.9/1.6/0.9) with P: (<or = 0.001/<or = 0.004/<or = 0.056). The kappa of the interobserver variability was 0.75 for the TFE sequence and 0.8 for the b-TFE sequence. The measured vessel lengths were longer for the TFE sequence (95 +/- 22 mm) than for the b-TFE sequence (80 +/- 40 mm; P <or = 0.115). No significant changes (P <or = 0.074, P <or = 0.145) in diameter and vessel sharpness of the RCAs were observed between the TFE (2.4 +/- 0.3 mm, 60 % +/- 5) and b-TFE sequences (2.4 +/- 0.3 mm, 62 % +/- 6). The CNR was higher for the TFE sequence (10.1 +/- 3.4) than for the b-TFE sequence (6.6 +/- 2.1; P <or = 0.014). All ten main and proximal segments of the LM/LAD, which were examined exclusively with the TFE sequence, were visible with grade 2.5 and 2.1. The middle segment was visible in seven cases with grade 1.3. In three cases, the distal segment was visible with grade 0.5. The vessel length was 78 +/- 27 mm and the CNR 11.9 +/- 2.4. CONCLUSION: The conventional TFE technique has demonstrated good feasibility for cMRA at 3T. In its operational availability at 3T, the b-TFE sequence is inferior to the TFE sequence.
PURPOSE: To test the feasibility of k-space segmented gradient-echo pulse sequences for free-breathing coronary magnetic resonance angiography (cMRA) on a clinical 3T system. MATERIALS AND METHODS: T2-prepared, fat-suppressed turbo field echo (TFE, turboFLASH, SFPGR) as well as balanced TFE (b-TFE, trueFISP, FIESTA, segmented SSFP) sequences with navigator gating for prospective motion correction were applied on a 3T system equipped with a six-element phased-array cardiac coil. In 15 healthy volunteers, the right coronary artery (RCA) was examined with TFE and b-TFE sequences. Due to examination time limitations, the left coronary artery (LM/LAD) was examined exclusively with the TFE sequence in ten volunteers. Image quality was graded on a five point scale (0 = not visualized to 4 = excellent). The length, diameter and sharpness of the vessels and the contrast-to-noise ratios (CNR) were measured. RESULTS: 98 % of all major segments (proximal/middle/distal) of the RCA could be seen with the TFE sequence and 82 % with the b-TFE sequence. The image quality for the three segments was graded higher for the TFE sequence (2.7/2.7/1.5) than for the b-TFE sequence (1.9/1.6/0.9) with P: (<or = 0.001/<or = 0.004/<or = 0.056). The kappa of the interobserver variability was 0.75 for the TFE sequence and 0.8 for the b-TFE sequence. The measured vessel lengths were longer for the TFE sequence (95 +/- 22 mm) than for the b-TFE sequence (80 +/- 40 mm; P <or = 0.115). No significant changes (P <or = 0.074, P <or = 0.145) in diameter and vessel sharpness of the RCAs were observed between the TFE (2.4 +/- 0.3 mm, 60 % +/- 5) and b-TFE sequences (2.4 +/- 0.3 mm, 62 % +/- 6). The CNR was higher for the TFE sequence (10.1 +/- 3.4) than for the b-TFE sequence (6.6 +/- 2.1; P <or = 0.014). All ten main and proximal segments of the LM/LAD, which were examined exclusively with the TFE sequence, were visible with grade 2.5 and 2.1. The middle segment was visible in seven cases with grade 1.3. In three cases, the distal segment was visible with grade 0.5. The vessel length was 78 +/- 27 mm and the CNR 11.9 +/- 2.4. CONCLUSION: The conventional TFE technique has demonstrated good feasibility for cMRA at 3T. In its operational availability at 3T, the b-TFE sequence is inferior to the TFE sequence.